Asteroids - 36v section power problem

RGP

Meeter & Greeter
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
2,039CR
Hi everybody

Looking at an asteroids PCB that has some issues, board is watchdogging but also on checking all the voltages i'm not getting what I should have on the 36vAC rail.

I should have approx +/-22v on C86 and C87, however, i've not got that, i've got about 0.8v on C87 and -48v on C86.

My thoughts were the 4 x 1N4001 diodes so i've replaced these, one of the caps (C86) was leaking so that was also replaced and I replaced C87 as well. Both replaced with 470uf/35v caps.

I've verified i've got 36vAC by using the edges of C84 and C85 before they hit the diodes - I have 37vAC in total across those points.

I have everything else hooked up and when I power up I can hear the test mode beep going on and it resetting constantly but its very faint and no vector output because the LM7815/LM7915/LM7805 aren't producing the right voltages.

This is the place I always get a bit tied up in the power supplies as they don't seem to behave how I expect.

I've had the LM78xx/79xx regulators out of circuit to try and stabilise the DC side but the voltage never gets anywhere near 22v at the two capacitors.

I compared to another board which has some graphics issues and the voltages are right on there.

Puzzled....
 

RaveN

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
1 (100%)
Credits
1,325CR
The transformer and the diodes are doing their job properly.
With 36vAC, you'd expect a 48vDC total voltage (36v * 1.414 - 1.4) unloaded.

The problem is you have a floating voltage that needs to have reference to the circuit GND.
Assuming that you're measuring the DC voltages using the same GND, and that C86 and C87 are the right way round (I don't mean to insult your intelligence there), ensure that the GNDs on the 2 caps (C87 neg and C86 pos) have continuity, and that continuity is measured back to the centre tap GND (from the schematics, the negative on the big blue will do).
 

RGP

Meeter & Greeter
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
2,039CR
Thanks Andy and no intelligence insulted.

I believe I have the caps the right way round comparing them with another board and some pictures online.

I have traced all the circuit from the two 36v inputs at 20 and X to the various locations and then to the next component in line after the bridge rectification and everything goes back where it should.

This, as I say is the part of this I get the most trouble from as like you say, without a reference nothing works as current is attracted along the circuit.

If I measure across the two 36v terminals in AC mode on my meter I have about 38v which seems about right.

Its important to note here i'm not using a cab's wiring to do this, i'm using an atari brick but not an AR1 or AR2. The brick is actually from a raster game but its only the monitor thats different outputs across all of them.

My 36v is coming from the brick's windings and my +5 is coming from a JAMMA PSU on my regular test rig.

I'm not going to try anything else until someone replies or I find out more but i'm not connecting the GND from the brick to the board.

I assumed the GND was for the 10.3vDC side not a center tap on the transformer and just went to the 10.3 side of the AR1 and was used to produce regulated 5v for the board as the 36v goes straight to the pcb.

Am I right in thinking from what you've said and me being a bit stupid that the brick GND needs bringing into this?
 

Mitchell Gant

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
888CR
You definitely need the centre tap of the 36V AC taking from the transformer ("brick") to the PCB.

A quick look at a schematic shows that the 36V centre tap IS connected to the 10V DC GND pins on the output connector.

I hope you haven't done any damage as you could have had a quite high floating voltage difference between your two power supplies without a common ground.
 

RGP

Meeter & Greeter
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
2,039CR
Yes, I, RGP, do not know absolutely everything about everything and this is where I fall down.

When we talked at Blackpool, I can stand and chat logic level for ages.....

... but who the f**k was I to think I was big enough to take on an asteroids board with a watchdog problem - pffft, it's ONLY a watchdog, Like I haven't cleared 10 of those in the last month etc etc etc (insert a lot of big men's room talk here).

smiley4.gif


I happened upon a quick online chat with ColinD as well and he said "yeah, you stupid idiot you need that GND in there from the CT".

I've added the GND across to Z on the edge connector which is directly connected to A which is now in common with GND from my +5v supply.

I know a lot of everyone else use a proper AR / Brick setup but I just don't have that luxury at the moment so I figured - 5v is 5v isn't it no matter where it comes from.

But it all makes sense (well wiring sense anyway) that 36vAC has a CT GND which flows to the AR which then becomes a common GND to the board so everything is nicely looped back.

I only ran the board for a few seconds here and there without the CT GND connected.

I need a really good read on PSU's can you suggest some good background reading as I don't totally get the floating voltage thing with diodes.

Thanks to yourself, ColinD and RaveN for the assistance here.

I now have back my vector output and the beep running when the watchdog barks, if i disable the dog I can nicely see the test pattern on my scope.
 

Mitchell Gant

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
888CR
PSU ground referencing has often baffled me and I find it difficult to explain or find a good explanation online when I've looked in the past.

I found this that may be slightly helpful:

http://www.aptsources.com/resources/pdf/Floating%20Output.pdf

On your Asteroids setup although you can measure perfect 36V AC across the C84 and C85 caps there is no return path for any current to flow other than through the ground connection that should go back to the brick transformer centre tap. If you look at the Asteroids schematic it shows 36V AC coming in on J20 pins X and 20. If X is positive part of AC cycle, then 20 is negative measured with respect to it. So your meter measures correctly 36V AC across here.

But if X is positive current can try to flow through diode CR11 but then where? It can't charge the C87 cap or go through regulators because there's no return path from ground back to the transformer centre tap. It can't go backwards through CR12 either as it's reverse biased.

At the same time, pin 20 is negative but current can't flow from the transformer to ground, then on through regulator either or charge C86 either. And CR10 is reverse biased at this point too so no flow through there.

When the AC cycle reverses there can't be any current flow through CR10 or CR12 in the same way.

Gah, it's hard to describe clearly!!

I can offer some ground reference anecdotes.

1: My first job was medical maintenance in a hospital. We were dismantling an old heart monitor which had a 6" CRT display and could run off a 12V lead acid battery to be portable.

The CRT chassis had a nice 12V DC in, 6kV CRT anode output complete with small anode cap. I wanted to play with that! So we hooked it up to a 12V lead acid battery on the bench and tried to make spark to things.

I ended up in a discussion with my workmates and boss that when running on the battery on a clean wooden bench it would be perfectly safe to grab hold of the 6kV anode cap, as long as the battery and chassis are kept well away from and earth conduction path. They disagreed with my argument and said I'd get a 6000v shock.

I said well I'm in the right building if I'm wrong, grabbed hold of the anode cap with one hand, and watched the horrified look on their faces. I was perfectly fine and felt nothing, not even a tingle.

If I'd touched or gone anywhere near the battery though, I would have had a nasty shock! But as the battery was not connected to any earth, and only I was, there was nowhere for any current to flow.

I DON'T recommend anyone try that!

2: Arrange these words to create a story I might have heard from the horses mouth that turned out to be just amusing rather than a major news disaster item. It concerns a 3 phase 24V 400A transformer with an *unconnected* centre a tap and a rectifier with it's negative output *connected* to metalwork earth. So in this case the centre tap of the transformer must NOT connect to the earth/ground output or there will be a very large current flow.

Upgrading control wiring.

Transformer centre tap.

Metal earthed cabinet.

Engineer.

Accidental connection.

Before fuse blew.

Magic smoke.

High levels of embarrassment.

Fire alarm.

Oil rig.

A long way offshore.

3: I was trying to measure the voltage output to an LED on a battery powered handset that wasn't working.

It was plugged in to a 12V power supply to charge it, and I connected my meter black probe to the PSU negative. With my fingers I held the red probe on to the LED leg.

The meter read -22V DC! What! Where does 22V come from??? The LED output should be 0V or 3.3V. And there's only 12V DC input.

Turned out to be one LED leg was disconnected and mains noise pickup through my body holding the red meter probe directly. The LED conducted the positive half cycle of noise away to the PSU negative and back to earth, but blocked the negative half cycle. The multimeter is plenty sensitive (very high impedance) enough to pick up mains electric fields through my body and that's where the -22V came from.

My colleague only got 19V when he tried it, obviously he's not as powerful as me.
smiley36.gif
 

RaveN

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
1 (100%)
Credits
1,325CR
Don't be disheartened.
We don't all have the luxury of spending 3/4 years on an electronic engineering degree (or similar).
We learn these things as we go.

Mitchell Grant sums things up nicely. I don't think you need to read books about it necessarily (as you suggest).
For arcade stuff, you just need to know the difference between centre-tap and twin secondaries (there's not a lot in it), the difference between full-wave and half-wave rectifiers (again, it's only voltage output that really differs) and then the GND reference.

Just remember that voltage is "potential difference", it's all relative. It's hard to explain especially for me), but a GND we create is a reference point (although sometimes we can connect it to earth GND). Say for example we had 2 separate power supplies, both 12v DC. In theory I could connect the GND from one to the 12v of the other, and create a 24v-0v supply. In reality that may not work, but you should get the idea of a reference point.

The 36vAC on the Atari is centre-tapped, so you can imagine it as 2 x 18vAC supplies (similar to having 2 x 18vAC secondaries with less flexibility, with the secondaries being connected together). Without reference to the centre tap, it's just a 36v sine wave, but as long as that centre tap is connected to a reference GND then it's a sine wave passing through your "0".

I did come up with an example, but then rather embarrassingly confused myself a bit :)

Remember though, if anything uses 2 separate power sources, you will likely need to connect the common GNDs together if they interact.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RGP

RGP

Meeter & Greeter
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
2,039CR
Thanks again Andy, that and Mitchell Grant's explanation have made it more clear now, i'll absorb the floating earth notes over a coffee or 20.

Out of everything, the most sound arcade tech advice for bench repair work comes in your very last line - the thing this all boiled down to.

RaveN said:
... if anything uses 2 separate power sources, you will likely need to connect the common GNDs together if they interact

Thanks you good sirs
smiley4.gif


I've now also fixed the watchdogging issue on the board and it seems to be running fine again.

Any suggestions for getting the right voltage for a 10" vector monitor like a G05? They use an odd voltage - am I ok to get a transformer which will provide the correct voltage? I know it needs to be an isolation transformer but my understanding is that most are in the way we need them to be (ie, the windings are physically separate). Its only really old supplies i've encountered where they use a 2:1 un-isolated step-down transformer and then a 1:1 isolation transformer.
 

RaveN

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
1 (100%)
Credits
1,325CR
I've now also fixed the watchdogging issue on the board and it seems to be running fine again.
smiley32.gif


As far as I'm concerned, all transformers that concern "us" (laminated, toroidal) are ALL isolation transformers, in that for them to work their operation means the primary/secondary are completely isolated.
Technically, ISO transformers are specified as having something like 16kv+ protection between the pri/sec (That value is guessed, but you get the point).

I don't know the voltages for a G05, but it's definitely possible!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RGP
Top