Cheap USB EPROM Programmer Recommendations?

Dave2084

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
456CR
Hi All,

As my main PC no longer has a Parallel port my trusty Elnec EPROM Programmer is less useful.

I can still use it but the only PC we have with Parallel ports is in my daughters bedroom ...

So I'm on the hunt for a cheap USB programmer that I can use most of the time and only resort to my main one when a cheap one doesn't cut the mustard.

I need support for 2716 to 27080 for it to be useful and in an ideal world it would support 2516/2532 as well.

Must be USB and must be able to work in a Windows VM under OSX Mavericks.

Any recommendations?
 

silverfox0786

Beware the Hillman
Feedback
47 (100%)
Credits
2,699CR
the GQ-4x can do all of above I have had it and for them its great but its has 1 let down and that is the Adaptors. The moment a chip needs a adaptor like the 16bit eproms then you have issues and the programmer fails more than its successes in writing chips (approx. £80)

The Minipro is my personal favourite and has many chips it can do natively but is limited to JEDEC chips of 40 pins or less, it cant do maskrom eproms (like the 27C400) and cant do more than 40 pin chips. I still rank this as my number 1 programmer as it has never given me a failed write or a verify mismatch yet (Approx. £40)

the other programmer I have personally tried is a TOP3100 and yes it does the larger chips natively like the 27C322 and 27c160 Maskrom type as well as JEDEC and has a 48PIN ZIF on it. I actually would not recommend it personally (Approx. £150)

the other which I have not used but want to buy but at £400 its above my budget is the
XELTEK SUPERPRO 600P

it will do pretty much every common chip and then some

hope this helps you
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
I'd be very tempted to check out the Batronix programmers:
http://www.batronix.com/shop/programmer/eprom-programmer.html

Around the £110 mark. The software claims to be Windows and OS X because it's written in Mono. When I downloaded the software to try it simply didn't work and after contacting their support I understood why, it relies on an old version of Mono which I can't install as I program for the latest version. That said, they will be looking to bring the software up to date soon (they did give me a tile scale, but I forget what it was) and in the meantime, it would certainly work in a VM (or Bootcamp if you had to).

You'd best check out the device lists and try the software as I've not really checked too much against your requirements, but I'm sure you would anyway
smiley2.gif
 

Adrian Purser

Moderator
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
213CR
I have a MiniPRO and I'm fairly happy with it but it can't program 2716 which is a big let down for me. My workshop PC is old enough to have a parallel port so I'm still using my old EMP20 a lot of the time.
 

Dave2084

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
456CR
guddler said:
The software claims to be Windows and OS X because it's written in Mono. When I downloaded the software to try it simply didn't work and after contacting their support I understood why, it relies on an old version of Mono which I can't install as I program for the latest version.

To be honest quite happy to run under VMware. When I went mac I was thinking mono would be great and allow some programs I still use to run natively in OSX, however, it looks crap on a Retina macbook wheras windows 8.1 runs nicely as a VM.
 

Dave2084

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
456CR
Tempted my Minipro but I really need 2716 as I probably program them the most.

So, considering GQ-4x.

Will have to install the software in my VM and try it out.

Thanks all!
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
BTW - Mono lookjng crap days are pretty much behind us now as most Mono is bound to native interfaces now. Bit concerned about Xamarin's lack of support for anything that isn't mobile though since they bought out Mono or whatever it was they did
smiley6.gif


Handy to know that doesn't work with 2716's though as I nearly bought one as a second programmer a little while back (hence why I was looking) and I think I've have expected 2716 as well. It's probably the 21v programming voltage variants I guess (or is it 25v?).
 

cmonkey

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
4 (100%)
Credits
1,659CR
I've got a MiniPro and whilst I can't speak about whether it actually can burn 2716's (as I simply don't have any 2716 eproms!) it does list support for the following 2716 devices in the current version of the software that I'm using (v6.00)

AMD AM2716B

CATALYST (CSI) CAT27C16

FAIRCHILD NMC27C16

FAIRCHILD NMC27C16B

FAIRCHILD NMC27C16Q

FUJITSU MBM2716

INTEL M2716

NSC NMC27C16

NSC NMC27C16B

NSC NMC27C16Q

SGS-THOMPSON ETC2716

SGS-THOMPSON M2716

TI TMS2716

Most of those are 21v Vpp with a couple of 12.5v Vpp thrown in to the mix. Like I said, I can't vouch for whether the programmer can actually burn those chips successfully as I don't have any of those chips, but I can't imagine they'd list them in the device selector unless it could do.
 

Dave2084

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
456CR
I'd really like to get another Elnec as the software support is second to none. My old programmer still gets monthly software updates!

The MEMProg2 is £250 from Rapid ... just wonder how it performs in a VM (if not I suppose bootcamp is more or less guaranteed).

Anyone fancy my PrePROM02-ALV?

Parallel port interface but in perfect condition (might even have the box somewhere)!
 

silverfox0786

Beware the Hillman
Feedback
47 (100%)
Credits
2,699CR
I program a lot of 2716 and yes the minipro cant handle them for some reason

2732 are fine but not 2716

I think its because the minipro has a max of 21V PGM and the 2716 requires 25V

I use my TOP3100 for 2716

btw OP are you looking into this for Atari VCS?
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
Not all 2716's require 25v but regardless, has anyone with a MiniPro considered taking it up with their support? Or is it one of these Chinese things with no support.
 

silverfox0786

Beware the Hillman
Feedback
47 (100%)
Credits
2,699CR
minipros are Chinese yes, but they do have a website so im sure a support ticket could be raised

the list says yes but the computer says no

there are lot of chips the minipro lists but does not do

the 2716 I have use 25V and in the miniprto they fail and on the top3100 if you set to 12.5v or 21v they fail but if you set to 25V they write and verify perfectly
 

Dave2084

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
456CR
silverfox0786 said:
btw OP are you looking into this for Atari VCS?

No, mostly classic arcade video games and early solid state pinball.

cmonkey said:
Dunno why people still use 2716's anyway, get with the modern world and migrate to 28c16's!!
smiley36.gif

Because I have 100's of 2716s already.
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
Same here. I don't have 100's, but I've only bought maybe 4 ROMs in the last 10 years and 3 of them were 16bit, 1 an EEPROM. When it comes to having to buy new ROMs then that tip will be duly noted
smiley36.gif


[EDIT] Having said that - a very early hit on Google shows the data sheet only gives 10 years retention. So 2816's are fine if you're developing or prototyping etc., but I've owned games for longer than 10 years now (one of them 14 years) and so I'd probably not want to replace 2716's with them.
guddler2014-07-01 09:39:27
 

Judder

Active member
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
1,009CR
Dave2084 said:
So, considering GQ-4x.

Hi Dave

GQ-4X is excellent and does 2532s and 2716s perfectly - many a Defender ROM board has been rescued from dead using my one of these :)

2732s for Galaga all fine so pretty much everything you need for vintage board fixing.

(NB: the earlier GQ-3X doesn't have support for 2532s I believe...)

Doesn't seem to do PROMs though, which I was looking at for Galaga but then I thought one of the cheapy Chinese ones would probably do that and be complementary.

HTH

Judder2014-07-01 10:23:30
 
Top