Model 3 Medium Res Monitors

Outrun2

Colonel Outrun
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
1,182CR
Anyone with Model 2/3 stuff that has experience with the differences between an MS9 with a Hitachi tube and a Toshiba tube?

I have different tubes in each side of my Daytona 2 and now that both sides are nearly fully restored and fully working I'm comparing the output from both and noticing a marked difference. The Toshiba tube has always given a stronger, more punchy image than the Hitachi, but I've recently noticed a definite 'graininess' to the Hitachi tube which just isn't noticeable on the Tosh. I'd like to get a more punchy image out of the Hitachi tube if possible, but as contrast and brightness adjustments haven't helped that might mean delving into tweaks I've not attempted before, so I'll leave that for now!

Although I have numerous 31K monitors, I only have these two 24K screens so I'm wondering if this is common to the Hitachi tube or if mine is somehow degrading. As usual with CRTs it's hard to capture on an average spec smartphone, but here goes:

Hitachi on the left/first, Toshiba on the right/second

51300001977_6c262c1bcc_c.jpg
51301457839_261c63499f_c.jpg


Hitachi on the left/first, Toshiba on the right/second

51301457769_86e1df8e9e_c.jpg
51301760735_4226901f05_c.jpg


I haven't taken full screen photos as it doesn't really show up on the photo, but is quite clear when viewed in the flesh. And really obvious when you play one cab and then the other. You can also see the issue when the screens are off so this is why I'm assuming it's a tube thing - you can see the honeycomb pattern clearly on the Hitachi.

Anyone have anything to suggest, or is this just a Friday night waffle about first world issues?
smiley36.gif
 

tb2000

Active member
Feedback
4 (100%)
Credits
3,579CR
Could be slightly different electrical characteristics of the crts in question but it looks to me like your convergence is slightly off on the Hitachi. Also the stripe pitch on the Toshiba looks slightly tighter than the Hitachi. Just different manufacturing processes from different manufacturers.
 

Outrun2

Colonel Outrun
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
1,182CR
Cheers Tony, convergence is far from perfect on either CRT to be honest, but I'm not sure I'll be up for tweaking that. I have to access the rear of the cab from outside the garage and can't see the screen even with a mirror as visibility is, errrm.. slightly restricted
smiley36.gif


51302263823_9a3ca69c41_b.jpg


This image makes it look a lot worse than it is but but does magnify the issue..

51302050346_fa0b3319de_c.jpg


Test pattern..

51301305892_efbba79e85_b.jpg


I'd like to see another MS9 coupled to a Hitachi tube to compare and see if it is 'normal'.
 

Vamino

Insert coin(s)
vacBacker
Feedback
23 (100%)
Credits
2,700CR
I've noticed the same thing mate.

When I took my old UK twin Daytona 2 cab to the last revival I had to replace one of the Hitachi monitors at the last minute for a Toshiba one off my Japanese cab. Side by side you could tell but after a bit of tinkering the difference wasn't so big, but it was still there if you looked hard enough.

These days my motto is a working monitor is a good one.

Toshiba tubes seem to have the most pleasing image. I've got a UK Scud Race with Hitachi monitors but have never tuned it on as it's been in storage since I bought it!
smiley36.gif


I remember trading a virtually burn free Tosh MS9 with a fantastic picture for a MS2932 with slight burn. At the time I needed the MS2932 for my 1st F355, but as time has gone on I now know how difficult it is to find nice Toshiba MS9 monitors. Ah well, you live and learn.
 

John Bennett

Senior Member
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
5,332CR
It's never easy counting the dots, but looks like the Toshiba has a higher dot pitch than the Hitachi.

If you look above the steering wheel, there's maybe 30% more dots on the Toshiba between the wheel and the black line. Looks more horizontally too, if not so many.

The more phosphor dots, the better pixels are going to look. They don't align with pixels, but the more, the merrier for drawing pixels (and this is why you'd never get something like HD on a tube like that as they're orders of magnitude lower than PC monitors were).

As said, convergence looks a tad off on the Hitachi too.

It might just be the above, but as maybe a separate issue the text blur looks a tad like my Crisis Zone that had a poor video out - weak drive signal perhaps, so the pixels didn't pull down to black so well and bled into each other. Do both PCB stacks output the same text when put on that same monitor?
 

Outrun2

Colonel Outrun
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
1,182CR
Yes, I think it must be dot pitch/TVL or whatever the right phrase is - basically how the screen is made up. This was mentioned as a possible reason over on AO https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_lines

Counting the dots/lines does confirm this. I always said a Toshiba tube gives the best image, but others have said a well tuned in Hitachi can give equal results - not sure that would be possible.

Vamino said:
..

These days my motto is a working monitor is a good one.

Toshiba tubes seem to have the most pleasing image. I've got a UK Scud Race with Hitachi monitors but have never tuned it on as it's been in storage since I bought it!
smiley36.gif


..

Totally mate, I don't get too OCD about monitors believe it or not, despite the evidence this thread is providing!
smiley36.gif
I appreciate them when they give me an image I can enjoy - the only time I changed monitors around is when I was going boggle-eyed looking at the terrible Sanwa monitors in two of my original three initialD cabs - they were terrible but that was all down to the common Shanghai Novel tube issue
smiley12.gif


Both MS9 screens have burn, particularly the Toshiba tube, but I really don't mind as it's Daytona 2 burn so it really doesn't show at all when running. Your old cab has the Hitachi and I think it's Scud burn so just a ghost Sega logo in the bottom-right corner. I'd like to tweak the Hitachi to get a little more colour in it, but I'm guessing you would have already done most of the setting and I'm not up to adding convergence strips
smiley34.gif


That's classic you still have a cab in storage from the raid years - one day mate you have that lineup of Sega drivers in a nice place that's not your lounge/conservatory!
smiley17.gif
 

Kev A

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
8 (100%)
Credits
747CR
I have an ms9 with a Hitachi tube in my SR2 it does have a slightly more grainy image than the 25" polo SR1 next to it. I always considered the polo to be "nicer" of the two. At one point I ran an SR1 board in the SR2 cab and side by side with the same game the ms9 looked great. It seemed to me the more detailed graphics of the m3 games seem to amplify the grainy look.
 

Vamino

Insert coin(s)
vacBacker
Feedback
23 (100%)
Credits
2,700CR
I wouldn't even suggest the notion that you have OCD tendancies, same as I don't have any either........yeah right!
smiley36.gif


I think John hit the nail on the head, I think it's down to the dot pitch. I guess some people prefer that dot pitch and other people don't. To my old eyes the Tosh is most pleasing.

If you haven't already recapped those monitors they would certainly benefit from being recapped. It may reduce the convergence and overall punch of the image. I did dial in the colours/screen/focus as best as I could at the time and I though it looked OK, but when the twin was at Paul's you could see the slight difference between the screens.

Not sure where that monitor came from mate. That cab was originally from Aztec and the whole cab was pretty much gubbed, I enjoyed restoring it as it was my 1st proper restoration but the final result wasn't as cheap as I envisioned! It was only due to the generosity of Stuart at Coin Gaming that I got the twin up and running again, we parted out a D2 DX to revive your cab as I think the screen had gone on the DX.

Anyhoo, I think one of the monitors may have failed and I may have stuck a monitor I got from JNC in it, or it was from the twin I bought from Coin games, I can't remember! Actually, my current twin Scud Race was an eBay purchase. The seller was a seaside arcade and the auction was for a twin Scud and a single Jp D2, that's the only reason I sold you that D2 for so cheap as I still had a twin with that extra single.

Well half of the UK Daytona 2 I took to revival has been sold so I've only got the twin Jp cab now. I'll be selling the other half of thre UK twin if I can fix the Sanwa monitor, heaven knows where that came from! I non destructively put Scud Race in it and I'm pretty sure the new owner is happy with it. I sold it for the same price I sold you the D2 for, I could have got more for it but I was happy to sell it at mates rates.
 

tb2000

Active member
Feedback
4 (100%)
Credits
3,579CR
I briefly worked on a Touring Cars Twin the other week and noticed that it had Hitachi crts on the MS9's both sides. They produced a nice picture (although both pcbs had issues) so I expect when both are the same you're not really going to notice the "imperfections".

I do have a Nanao MS9-29 crt in my storage that's an M68 crt (I don't recall the manufacturer at this time), to be honest i've never looked at it that closely to see if the stripe pitch is finer than the much more common A68 crts, and I can't remember what cab it must've come from but it does at least mean they used M (monitor) designation finer pitch crts in some Sega driving cabs for whatever reason! I thought it would've been with a 31k chassis but i'm 99.9% certain it's from an MS9-29. The only other M designation crts i'd seen in cabs before that were the ones used in Atari System 2 cabs like Paperboy and stuff like APB, 720 degrees, etc (oh, and obviously some vector cabs such as Tempest).

tb20002021-07-14 15:14:36
 

John Bennett

Senior Member
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
5,332CR
The dot pitch of these things is so close to the actual resolution - MS9-2931 is only 676*676 dots, so almost 1:1 at 31kHz 640x480 and maybe 1.5 dots per horizontal pixel at the typical medium-resolutions, so the best you ever get is a woolly approximation of the pixels.

This is why three-CRT projection systems rule
smiley4.gif
 
Top