68000 CPU versions

Purity

The Oracle
vacBacker
Feedback
17 (100%)
Credits
2,999CR
Quick question....Would you expect a HD68000P8 CPU to operate the same as a MC68000P12 CPU and vice versa?

I am trying to fix a PCB and I think there might be an issue with the CPU. I've moved the HD68000P8 to a PCB that I know boots but has issues, replacing the MC68000P12, the board does not boot. It hangs on the test screen. Does this indicate a failed CPU?
 

big10p

Coins detected in pocket!
vacBacker
Feedback
13 (100%)
Credits
6,092CR
That's not going to work surely, if the P suffix indicates clock speed. You'd be trying to overclock an 8mhz CPU to 12mhz. Just guessing here, though.
 

Martinmurphy30

User
vacBacker
Feedback
4 (100%)
Credits
421CR
You can over clock a 68k but I don't think it would work well over clocking by a third of the rated speed, this is probably causing it to crash. You could try the 12mhz CPU in the 8mhz board to see if it runs, should be fine I think.
 

mlynn

User
Credits
121CR
People who have swapped MC68000 CPUs for HD68000P8 on the Atari ST haven't experienced any problems because they are both designed to run at 8MHz. Some people have used it to try to reduce or debunk the bad DMA Chip Myth on the Atari STE.

I believe the Hitachi HD68000P8 uses less power than a Motorola MC68000 so overclocking it may increase power dissipation and cause instability. The TAS instruction might also cause problems if running overclocked depending on what other hardware share the address bus.

The MC680x0 instruction set reference describes its operation as:
Tests and sets the byte operand addressed by the effective address field. The instruction tests the current value of the operand and sets the N and Z condition bits appropriately. TAS also sets the high-order it of the operand. The operation uses a locked or read-modify-write transfer sequence. This instruction supports use of a flag or semaphore to coordinate several processors.

The atomicity is realized via a special bus cycle that external peripherals must not break.

mlynn2021-09-05 23:20:51
 

kenc

Newbie
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
19CR
The P indicates the package. Plastic DIP, in this case. The number after it is the maximum spec'd clockspeed. You can put faster parts in a slower design. But should n't put slower parts in a faster design. Yes, there will be some margin, but it's not massive and you reduce long term reliability. If the chips can run reliably at the faster speed, that's what the manufacturer would have sold them as. You also don't know how much of the margin the designer is already relying on. Even if the chip is within the clock spec, various individual signal setup/hold times may be close to the limit. Either intentionally or otherwise.

You should be able to replace any 68000 with a faster one. There's also a 68010 which has the same pins, but has some architectural differences that may be significant.
 

GadgetFreak

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
963CR
The number after the P is the clock speed. Replacing a 12Mhz part with an 8Mhz part will probably not work. Check the crystal on the board, often there is a dedicated crystal for the 68K CPU, it is probably a 12Mhz one on the board you are testing.
Sometimes you get 68K CPU's which are marked 8Mhz but are actually 12Mhz parts but due to price points and production rates were marked and sold as 8Mhz parts.
 

GadgetFreak

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
7 (100%)
Credits
963CR
Purity said:
I am trying to fix a PCB and I think there might be an issue with the CPU.  I've moved the HD68000P8 to a PCB that I know boots but has issues, replacing the MC68000P12, the board does not boot.
Should have asked this question straight away. What is both the original board and the "moved to" board as this would help to nail down the clock frequencies?
 
Top