ArcadePro legallity.

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
I've been thinking about this for about a week now and I can't come up with an answer.
How do companies like Home Leisure direct sell cabinets that contain a pandoras box with thousands of roms?

They do have a disclaimer on their website that says something to the effect of 'you're buying the hardware and the games are free'.
To my knowledge under UK copyright law this doesn't negate copyright infringment.

They can't have licensed every title. It doesn't make commercial sense.

Imagine the conversation with Capcom:

"We'd like permission to distribute Street Fighter II."

"Certainly. What platform?"

"A £60 Chinese emulation board containing 8,999 other games, many belonging to your competitors."

That meeting would be very short.
Is it a business risk that could turn round and ruin them if Nintendo and other developers decided to lawyer up or am I missing something?

I should add that I don't really care what they do, they can sell what they want and conduct their business however they see fit for me, I'm motivated to ask for the thoughts of others out of curiosity.

Cheers,

Sassy
 

ExZX

Active member
Feedback
35 (100%)
Credits
1,766CR
Easy one. Most of the companies (that still exist or own the rights) that made these games no longer care.
The only caveat may be something like for example trying to use the pacman character in your new arcade venture as part of the logo. Hence a cease and desist letter from Namco. Real example that one
 

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
You would think they would care about an international company selling their intellectual properties.

Nintendo for example have a history of suing people into the ground.

Its a big risk for a company to take.
If nintendo suddenly or others suddenly showed an interest it could ruin them many times over.
 

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
Yeh no ones cares , There are 1000's in pubs , clubs ect. When i went away 5 years or so ago they had closed the arcade and replaced with 3 shit multi cabs. Gutted !

Dave.
All the arcades round our way are now cranes, coin pusher, redemption machines.
I think Nobles has a sega rally 2 but thats about it for what I'd call proper games.
 

eliotcole

Active member
Feedback
8 (100%)
Credits
1,138CR
Shame, innit ... I was talking with Retroman8329 about this (on the 'epic' journey to Wigan) and I came to the conclusion that even if I ever DID have an arcade (or row, there-in) for public consumption that they'd be as good a cross-section as I could manage of single games. Even if those single games were running *through* a 'multi' or a 'mister' ... I'd just ensure that there's that old feeling of either just having a bit of fun with a mate (and maybe a beer, if it's a repro cab!) or wanting to beat the game, or get a high-score (not my drug of choice, but many's) ... or ... heck ... show off! 😅

Whatever ... *ANYTHING* to avoid that thing where it feels like the game itself is devalued ( yep, even the already shit ones 😏 ) by the fact that one can ... just ... change it off when it gets boring, a little hard, or something else ... y'know?

This is why I kind of prefer 'token' based modern arcades (as opposed to 'time-based free-play' ones) as there is (even if it is perhaps diminished) more feeling that one's current game matters just a *tiny* bit more. I mean, sure, I realise that this is all in my silly head. But, even when the arcade is ostensibly a freeplay arcade, because the tokens are unlimited, I tend to find it hard to just walk away from a machine, or engage a game changing mechanism.

Anyway ... I'm sure that is all ONE HUNDRED percent my nutty brain assigning value to a little coin based on NOTHING ... but ... yeah ... it feels a bit more 'right' ... I dunno.
 

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
Shame, innit ... I was talking with Retroman8329 about this (on the 'epic' journey to Wigan) and I came to the conclusion that even if I ever DID have an arcade (or row, there-in) for public consumption that they'd be as good a cross-section as I could manage of single games. Even if those single games were running *through* a 'multi' or a 'mister' ... I'd just ensure that there's that old feeling of either just having a bit of fun with a mate (and maybe a beer, if it's a repro cab!) or wanting to beat the game, or get a high-score (not my drug of choice, but many's) ... or ... heck ... show off! 😅

Whatever ... *ANYTHING* to avoid that thing where it feels like the game itself is devalued ( yep, even the already shit ones 😏 ) by the fact that one can ... just ... change it off when it gets boring, a little hard, or something else ... y'know?

This is why I kind of prefer 'token' based modern arcades (as opposed to 'time-based free-play' ones) as there is (even if it is perhaps diminished) more feeling that one's current game matters just a *tiny* bit more. I mean, sure, I realise that this is all in my silly head. But, even when the arcade is ostensibly a freeplay arcade, because the tokens are unlimited, I tend to find it hard to just walk away from a machine, or engage a game changing mechanism.

Anyway ... I'm sure that is all ONE HUNDRED percent my nutty brain assigning value to a little coin based on NOTHING ... but ... yeah ... it feels a bit more 'right' ... I dunno.
I agree, this is I think the best way I can relate.

Back when I was at school, I was lucky enough to have an amiga.

Copied games went round the playground faster than a dose of nits.

Because they were essentially free, I got no value out of 99% of them.

The small collection of original titles I'd amassed by working on a weekend and saving for were played time and time again.

You dont value stuff thats free (or appears to be) but the stuff you've payed for, you get more out of it.

I dont like the way amusements have changed but I can't do much about it.

I dont have any arcade clubs near me so thats out of the window too.

The above makes me sad because Im one of those nostalgic people.
I should imagine 99% of the people on this forum are too.

And another thing....

With retro games, we had 8 bit computers and consoles to compare them to.
Even when the 16 bit stuff came along, most of the arcade games were a cut above them.

Now everything's just the same as this generations consoles.
Makes me wonder where it will go next.

Plus coin pusher, cranes, redemption stuff, they inhale pound coins like they're going out of fashion.

I can't see many operators putting many retro games in, they just won't earn as much per square meter.
 

eliotcole

Active member
Feedback
8 (100%)
Credits
1,138CR
I think that there's still things that you can do, but they would all ostensibly end up having a reasonable amount of work for you and those who'd be involved.
I dont like the way amusements have changed but I can't do much about it.

I dont have any arcade clubs near me so thats out of the window too.

The above makes me sad because Im one of those nostalgic people.

I should imagine 99% of the people on this forum are too.

Me concentrating on this part isn't to detract from or dismissed the rest of your predicament, though ... it's a shame, truly.

Honestly, even pushing arcades out of the window for a second ... I struggle to find much of ANYTHING to do that allows for a drive and a day out that isn't wholly rote.



Still, back to the 'no arcade clubs' thing ... and the idea that's cropped up a few times in my mind is effectively starting a 'member's club' of sorts. But ... y'know ... officially licenced by whatever local authority needs to do it (however that is done) because any such thing would invariably require money to run ... right?

That's because you'd collectively need to secure a space to meet (at first, because there's zero chance of just spinning up even a *small* arcade of even 4-5 cabs) that will allow y'all to bring circuit-boards, monitors, etc ... hang out ... fix ... borrow tools and expertise ... and ostensibly do all the things that you'd really want to use such a community for.

Unless someone has an 'in' or something, that's not going to be free ... plus it'll require copious amounts of electricity. A pub/cafe would kind of be the wrong environment for this kind of thing, I think, which was thinking more along the lines of something like a Scout Hut or Town Hall, you know?

Eventually it should become reasonably watertight, allowing for slightly more permanent digs. Perhaps a really cheap warehouse space, or a storage company that turns a blind eye to 15 nerds huddling in a lock space! 😅 Then, my friend ... you have *finally* got that little local arcade AND a community ... all in one.

Plus, if it all works out, I dare say that you could add value to the local community by taking the folks from the club and starting a local 'fix it' thing for residents to come and learn how to or muddle through together (just with tools/expertise that they'd otherwise not have) and bring back old vacuums, TVs, and PCs! 🤓
 

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
I don't know anything about the specific product mentioned, but speaking generally there have been a few cases where manufacturers have taken action when they felt their trademarks were being infringed.

https://nypost.com/2017/08/11/arcade-company-accused-of-selling-fake-pac-man-games/
I think they look at the bank balance of the Co.
Make an assessment on cost of litigation and go from there.

If the pot at the end of the rainbow isn’t worth it ?
I saw both of these when I got curios if any company had ever been taken to account for this kind of thing.
Like I said above, such a risky business decision to peddle ROMS.
 

John Bennett

Senior Member
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
5,324CR
I think companies like 'Atari' you wouldn't want to upset - businesses that own the name to an old company and are most likely to be scouring the scene looking for people using the branding they now own.
But I think that would be sticking their branding on stuff rather than some Romz on an iffy pandora PCB.
 

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
I think they look at the bank balance of the Co.
Make an assessment on cost of litigation and go from there.

If the pot at the end of the rainbow isn’t worth it ?
oh yeah, for sure.
If the business and individuals involved don't have a pot to piss in anyway then what's the point.
You can't get blood out of a stone but you'd maybe think there would be a couple of cease and desist type letters sent.
 

SassMate

Newbie
vacBacker
Credits
122CR
I think that there's still things that you can do, but they would all ostensibly end up having a reasonable amount of work for you and those who'd be involved.


Me concentrating on this part isn't to detract from or dismissed the rest of your predicament, though ... it's a shame, truly.

Honestly, even pushing arcades out of the window for a second ... I struggle to find much of ANYTHING to do that allows for a drive and a day out that isn't wholly rote.




Still, back to the 'no arcade clubs' thing ... and the idea that's cropped up a few times in my mind is effectively starting a 'member's club' of sorts. But ... y'know ... officially licenced by whatever local authority needs to do it (however that is done) because any such thing would invariably require money to run ... right?

That's because you'd collectively need to secure a space to meet (at first, because there's zero chance of just spinning up even a *small* arcade of even 4-5 cabs) that will allow y'all to bring circuit-boards, monitors, etc ... hang out ... fix ... borrow tools and expertise ... and ostensibly do all the things that you'd really want to use such a community for.

Unless someone has an 'in' or something, that's not going to be free ... plus it'll require copious amounts of electricity. A pub/cafe would kind of be the wrong environment for this kind of thing, I think, which was thinking more along the lines of something like a Scout Hut or Town Hall, you know?

Eventually it should become reasonably watertight, allowing for slightly more permanent digs. Perhaps a really cheap warehouse space, or a storage company that turns a blind eye to 15 nerds huddling in a lock space! 😅 Then, my friend ... you have *finally* got that little local arcade AND a community ... all in one.

Plus, if it all works out, I dare say that you could add value to the local community by taking the folks from the club and starting a local 'fix it' thing for residents to come and learn how to or muddle through together (just with tools/expertise that they'd otherwise not have) and bring back old vacuums, TVs, and PCs! 🤓
That's a great idea.
A lot of variables though.
I tihnk whichever way you went about starting your own arcade club it would be hard graft and probably costly.
I've got a handful of cabs and not much time on my hands.

I am trying to get into the industry in some capacity, the hard bit for me at the moment is trying to figure out where I could fit in.
The dream for me would be amassing a fleet of cabs and getting them in venues on a revenue share.
Not necessarily arcades/amusements, more cafes, kebab shops, pubs, holiday parks, launderettes etc.
Anywhere where people spend enough time to chuck a quid or two in an SF2 cab for old times sake or to pass a few minutes.
I'm going to kick the ball in that direction and if it doesn't work out then I'll be happy just buying broken stuff, fixing it and selling it on.
I don't have a lot to lose. Everything I've bought was broken in some way or another and was purchased at a price that was way below what it's worth now.

I'd love to see a return to the old days but I also know it's not going to happen.
Especially not in a tourist town like the one I live in at the moment.
 

Retroman839

Senior Member
vacBacker
Feedback
13 (100%)
Credits
8,288CR
Like evercade would be a killer app if
Mame had never existed.

I’m guessing capcom , Atari , neo geo , toaplan , Konami ,data east , item , jaleco get royalties from evercade ?


How well would evercade have sold if we had no mame up until evercades release .
 

Retroman839

Senior Member
vacBacker
Feedback
13 (100%)
Credits
8,288CR
Arcade 1up
Pay royalties but under the toy / domestic licence rather than commercial .

But some place do stick em into some places like cafes /bars / shops.

But I guess that’s not arcade 1ups fault right ?

Mame emulating hardware you can argue create the gun . The spark is the rom.

If you create a bomb then a
Contract that says you are not liable for any harm created but this bomb

Then you sell the bomb but first you getting the person to sign the contract .
 

69er

Active member
Feedback
6 (100%)
Credits
1,841CR
That's a great idea.
A lot of variables though.
I tihnk whichever way you went about starting your own arcade club it would be hard graft and probably costly.
I've got a handful of cabs and not much time on my hands.

I am trying to get into the industry in some capacity, the hard bit for me at the moment is trying to figure out where I could fit in.
The dream for me would be amassing a fleet of cabs and getting them in venues on a revenue share.
Not necessarily arcades/amusements, more cafes, kebab shops, pubs, holiday parks, launderettes etc.
Anywhere where people spend enough time to chuck a quid or two in an SF2 cab for old times sake or to pass a few minutes.
I'm going to kick the ball in that direction and if it doesn't work out then I'll be happy just buying broken stuff, fixing it and selling it on.
I don't have a lot to lose. Everything I've bought was broken in some way or another and was purchased at a price that was way below what it's worth now.

I'd love to see a return to the old days but I also know it's not going to happen.
Especially not in a tourist town like the one I live in at the moment.

It’s probably going to remain a dream unfortunately? But it’s a great line of work to be in … I have been there done that got the T shirts ( and the hoodies, hi viz vests, tail lift vans, business cards, etc etc)

Sadly few people now deal in cash coin or even have stocks of coin change… most banks charge a fee to issue bulk bags of coin… First off you need to become a business, get a UTR with HMRC gateway.
Think about public liability insurance.. if someone got a shock off a machine .. assuming it’s had a valid PAT test on site and not had risk factors exposed later?

Shops/cafes rarely want extra people inside where they could fit in a table .. or display shelves…. takeaways maybe??? But what stops someone saying they are changing your machine for you and just steal it? YOU can’t insure a machine on a site you don’t own and would have to have the site include it on their contents policy if it’s likely permanent?

You could get a lock up unit or even a container with electric supply to house some replacement stock and a good van to truck them round and trolley trucks to navigate paved zones and despite disability access rules prepare to meet stairs/steps and narrow doorways and corridors.. and don’t dare rip wallpaper or paintwork installing you might end up with a bill to redecorate?

You need a good personal approach to those places … Pubs are the best sites but only free trade tenanted pubs will allow input of equipment .. managed brewery owned sites are tied to major suppliers only and you would need be on the preferred list of suppliers. Most have a supplier already as do holiday parks (which are seasonal only earning for summer 6 weeks and a few weekends)

It can work but it’s tough.. and be prepared to deface your games with cash box ‘motorway bars’ or padlock hasps as a standard cam lock can be popped in seconds losing you the income and probably the coin box too!

Leisure centres / bowling alleys often same applies but you need to contact the local or county councils and get on their books as amusements and sport leisure suppliers.

On all sites you may need to battle the big companies? Who also want good sites. They even employ site finders.. it’s like trying to build a window cleaning round where several others operate already?

In many cases you may need to offer more than video cabs …. Quiz games, pool tables etc don’t need licence to operate and can be offered on shares basis but all this needs a reliable back up service call out…. Coin jam probably a lolly stick in the slot prevents a whole days takings and an irate site owner results … assuming he believes it worth plugging in and turning on/off daily?

The 1980s was as you say the best time to do this but many opportunists jumped on it in chippies around 1990 so that too got flooded as within a few hundred yards up some streets several machines were available to play… you need a number of single site machines so the good earners support the poorer ones which can have odd periods of good taking if buttons don’t get stuck with greasy chips/fish batter all up the greasy fingermarked glass screen too…. Who cleans them … afraid it’s probably you! Only clean machines get played….

Look at motorway services no video games are supplied nowadays as big prize fruits take priority but gaming licensing is a whole new story… tho good to get in at present with current supply laws but you need be VAT registered. And licensed by gambling commission. They ensure you pay vat on all takings and suggest you make a ‘mandatory’ small 1-2% donation to gamcare or gambleaware and display anti gambling stickers on your machines.. sorry drifting a bit ….


Meanwhile……

My best tip is start in a manageable casual way and when you have some credibility expand to other fields I mention
Start with an easy stock suitable coin op round with perhaps Tomy/Beaver venders .. 20p - £2 operated coin only products cost around 50% of release coin value so offer 25% of takings to site such as pet shops hardware shops newsagents etc especially if they put out pavement displays every day but you need to chain them to a wall bracket or drainpipe? Fit in a car easy to manage but easy to steal or damage to rob coins or product….

If you get a good beaver site have them fit a visible outdoor power socket and offer them a kiddie ride on shares but remember that public liability insurance else a poor families kid will fall off deliberately and the parent will sue you for injury….

Pool tables earn 50p-£2 but you need supply cues which lose tips, or snap balls go missing or pockets jam with alsorts from fag packets, plastic cups, knickers, handkerchiefs and paper often on purpose to keep the balls up for free play?
Than re-clothing in the event of a rip or a pint of Guinness spilling? All adds to the fun of owning sited equipment!!!

If that hasn’t put you off … good luck it can be done but think it through fully.
 
Last edited:

John Bennett

Senior Member
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
5,324CR
Like evercade would be a killer app if
Mame had never existed.

I’m guessing capcom , Atari , neo geo , toaplan , Konami ,data east , item , jaleco get royalties from evercade ?


How well would evercade have sold if we had no mame up until evercades release .
A quick glance and it looks like companies actually release their games for Evercade, rather than it being something stuffed full of ROMs like a Pandora.

I'd say a huge amount of stuff owes its existence to MAME, what with it being open source and leading the way in emulating a lot of things first. That's why it's shitty when people take it, read it, maybe run it through A.I. and then create something commercial or via Patreon.
I doubt even you'd have have MiSTer, AES+, Hamster ports, many of those virtual console/arcade classic collections and all the deluge of A.I. driven emulators if it wasn't for MAME.
 
Top