Cheap FPGA ??

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
Is there such a thing?

I'm working on a hardware project (for Vectrex as it goes, not really arcade) and at the moment it's a one off as the target is very specific little dev board thing that I have, primarily because one of the major design goals has always been that it must use stuff I had lying around and involve absolute minimal outlay on new stuff.

But once I'm done it's highly likely that other people will be interested.

So what's the cheepest make / model of FPGA you can get?

I know it depends somewhat on the spec and requirements. I know a few of them now but I don't know the size requirement until I'm done.

  • 29 I/O pins
  • Implements 2 block memories. One small (512 bytes), may be able to optimise smaller, one large 32k (emulates a 27256 RAM) - 64k would be nice but not essential.
  • Can't remember the clock. My dev board has 50Mhz on board.
The dev board, at the moment is a Spartan 3E 500. But I know they're not cheap.

Anything else fit the bill or is it a pipe dream?
 

Macro

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
4 (100%)
Credits
2,009CR
$38 for the Papillio 250k, but that only has 24k of block ram
$65 for the Papillio 500k with 40k

clock is irrelevant as you should be able to use a DCM to get whatever you need (but papilios have 32Mhz)

I have seen other project boards in my searches, but I need more RAM for my next project, so waiting on the successor to the papillio pro which has been mentioned in the forums. (or I'll just get a pipistrello!)
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
Ah. Just looked that up and it's not what I meant.

That's a dev board. I meant FPGA chip for putting on a final design...

Not that it'll ever happen i doubt but you never know.
 

DaveAS

User
Credits
336CR
Depends on the amount of logic. You'll struggle to find anything cheap with the amount of RAM you're after and may be better off coupling a small FPGA to an external SRAM. A chip with internal configuration memory has the advantage of no external flash requirement and wouldn't get ripped off (at least not easily) if you came up with something that sold well.

Lattice ICE40 - some cheap parts available (under 3 quid). OTP, although you can program in-circuit without flashing for development, assuming you power the prototype cart externally so you can reset the Vectrex.
Microsemi Igloo/Proasic3 - again, cheap parts and this time you can reprogram. Some nice package sizes that take the pain out of soldering. Downside is it's quite hard to source much of the range in low volumes for some reason. I originally designed my Firefox LD board around Igloo and had to rework when I couldn't get any parts for love nor money.
Lattice XP2 - more expensive, reprogrammable, plentiful supply from the usual suspects.

Also consider CPLDs if you don't have much logic.

Best bet is to use the parameterised search on Digikey to decide what you want and then sort by price.

An FPGA-based Vectrex cart opens up soooo many possibilities. It's on my list of projects I'll never get around to. :) It'd be cool to use the console's processor purely to move vectors and run another processor on the FPGA for game logic.

--
Dave
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
Cheers Dave - that Igloo Nano is ridiculously small
smiley1.gif


I'll have to have a look into this, but there's some nice options there. I very much suspect that I'll never go beyond the single unit that I already have - depends what it evolves into. At the moment there's not much logic but I am implementing bluetooth comms between PC and cart so that's about to change.
 

Adrian Purser

Moderator
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
213CR

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
You know, I think I've looked at them before. I've been a bit curious to explore other makes of tool chain than just Xilinix which is all I've used so far. I've more or less got to grips with it now (as much as a non EE layman can anyway!) but it's still very complex for what I'm doing with it - at least it feels like it is to me anyway.

The voltage level conversion is always going to be a problem. The only stuff that seems to be 5v compatible these days is Arduino and clones, everything else seems to be 3.3v. The go-dil that I'm using at the moment is only 5v compatible because they've added the conversion buffers, or level shifters, or whatever they are.

The nice thing about a module like that is that the level shifters would probably happily fit on the main card which, let's face it would not need to be any bigger than the daughterboard apart from where it needs to plug in to the slot.
 

DaveAS

User
Credits
336CR
TI have a selection of bus transceivers with level conversion, including many with automatic handling of bidirectional signals.

See:

http://www.ti.com/logic/docs/translationselection.tsp?sectionId=458

Density is quite impressive with single devices handling up to 32-bits.

74LCX parts are a 5V tolerant subset of 74LS and provide a cheaper alternative with fairly high drive strength. Powered at 3.3V, output levels are compatible with 5V TTL inputs. Downsides are low density and the need to provide bidirectional control from the FPGA.

--
Dave

VicViper2013-11-24 13:58:11
 
Top