Monitor Interference From Lighting Ballast

big10p

Coins detected in pocket!
vacBacker
Feedback
13 (100%)
Credits
6,088CR
Got them today so thought I'd have a go at fitting. First, here's what you get:

kit.jpg


[edit] Gah! I forgot to put the link cable in the shot! D'oh!
smiley9.gif


So, the unit LED unit itself, power cable, link cable (up to 10 units can be linked!) and 2 kinds of bracket, which could be useful. It does have the usual cheap Chinese feel to it, I have to say, but as long as it works OK, I'm not bothered. Here's the specs of the LED unit (it has 32 LEDs, BTW):

specs.jpg


As you can see, the lens is sort of ribbed, but this does little to diffuse the light, unfortunately. After switching on to test, and holding an old marquee I had knocking around in front of it, the light shining through looked pretty bright, but distrinctly spotty!
smiley18.gif
Anyway, looked around for something to diffuse the light more, and found a textured, transparent plastic folder I had worked well, when placed directly behind the marquee. No spots!
smiley1.gif


Turned out this wasn't needed though, with the actual cab marquee, which is back-painted glass, whereas the test marquee is plastic. Not quite sure why this is - just glad I didn't have to use anything to diffuse the light, after all.

However, I did experiment to find the optimal distance to mount the strip away from marquee. Turned out to be approx 2 inches. Any closer to the marquee and I could start to see spotting, and even horizontal lines in the light, caused by the ribbed lens.

Before mounting, here's a size comparison with the existing fluorescent tube:

comparison.jpg


As you can see, it's a fair bit shorter and thinner. Hopefully this won't make too much difference!

After removing all the fluorescent gubbins, I simply cut and connected the power cable to the existing 240v input cable, using a terminal block. Simples!

fitting.jpg


Time to switch on and make sure it's working OK:

20160514_165823.jpg


This pic is a bit misleading: while the strip is indeed pretty damn bright (look at it for more than about a second and it'll hurt your eyes!), in reality it looks MUCH more spotty than this. Anyway, time for the acid test and fit the marquee:

1LED.jpg


Looks pretty good to me!
smiley1.gif
For comparison, here's a pic with the original fluorescent bulb:

fluorescent_bulb.jpg


The fluorescent light is undeniably brighter than the LEDs, but not by a huge amount. As an experiment, I then plugged a second LED unit in, using the supplied link cable:

twin_fitting.jpg


After replacing the marquee and switching on, I was surprised to find it didn't seem that much brighter than just using 1 unit!
smiley5.gif
It's probably about the same brightness as the original fluorescent tube:

2LED.jpg


I want to do a final test when it gets dark, but I'm pretty sure I'm going to stick to using just 1 unit. The other unit will go into another cab.

In conclusion, I would definitely recommend these as a cheap(ish) LED replacement, but it seems it depends on your particular marquee as to whether you get spottiness or not. Just experiment like I did before fitting and use some kind of textured, transparent sheet (or something) fitted directly behind the marquee, if you get unacceptably spotty light!

Cheers.

big10p2016-05-14 18:59:56
 

big10p

Coins detected in pocket!
vacBacker
Feedback
13 (100%)
Credits
6,088CR
Hurray Banana said:
Looks good, could you slide one left and the other right a bit to get a bit wider coverage?
Sure, but I decided to stick with using just one unit. They actually do a 50cm version too, but I think that would be too wide for this cab, especially as you need a bit of extra room on the end for the power plug.

I may try painting the fixing board white.
big10p2016-05-15 11:20:54
 

big10p

Coins detected in pocket!
vacBacker
Feedback
13 (100%)
Credits
6,088CR
Just a quick update. I fitted the other LED strip to my other JAMMA cab - which has a repro marquee by muddymusic - and I get no spottiness in the light at all. Plenty bright enough, too.

The test marquee I was using was an old play-a-coin one, where only the letters 'PAC' are transparent, the rest is opaque. The letters are basically just fully transparent, with a red tint, which is why I could see the LED spots of light through it. I would guess this wouldn't be an issue with most other marquees.

So yes, I would definitely recommend these as a replacement for fluorescent marquee lights.
smiley1.gif
 
Top