Sub 74S for 74F?

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR
Hi all,

Due to being chronically braindead I chopped out a duff 74F32 and then realised I don't have any F replacement; I thought I had some ALS around but nope.

I do have some SN74S replacements and according to TI the switching time is ~4nS which is very close to the spec for an F.

I can't see any reason why this would be a problem (slight difference in current, but important?) so I thought I'd check the hive mind before soldering it in without a socket.

It's in a clock circuit for a 10M 68k board.

cheers
 

guddler

Busting vectors like it's 1982!
vacBacker
Feedback
10 (100%)
Credits
4,058CR
Given where it is, I think I'd be inclined to put it in a socket. I'm huge believer in never introducing the possibility of mechanical failure unnecessarily (AKA why the f*** does everyone insist on socketing logic chips!), but in this case, with it being in a clock circuit, I would.

I know you probably want to solder it in right now but somewhere I have a very heavy ice cream tube absolutely FULL of 'F' series logic if it helps??
 

PaulSwan

ZZZ
Feedback
1 (100%)
Credits
1,118CR
It's pretty close - I've seen 74S used in clock circuits before, more than likely OK. They also run hotter and thus tend to have a higher failure rate than usual LS (so you might like to consider a socket this time :) ), especially in clock circuits that are none-stop switching.
 

cliff_poole

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
6 (100%)
Credits
1,069CR
As far as sockets go, I was always told to use them because the PCB tracks can only stand up to a certain amount of re-soldering. If you have to replace the chip a second time, you increase the chances of lifting a track.

It is also my experience that socket contacts only become dodgy after years of being stored in poor conditions, i.e. damp lockup or back room.

Somtimes I use sockets sometimes I don't, just thought it'd be worth mentioning the reasons to balance it out a bit
smiley1.gif
.
 

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR
Socketed and subbed the 74S and it's been soaktesting for a good while now.

Cheers chaps - now to fix the original fault rather than the one I created first time around :)
 
Top