Atari Star Wars Questions

Equites

Chief Sheesher®
vacBacker
Feedback
35 (100%)
Credits
3,329CR
Dudes

Im hoping to be in the market for an Atari Star Wars cab this year, and have been reading up on whatever information is out there regarding these.

However, I do have a couple of questions which have not been answered properly.

Firstly, it appears that these cabs were originally supplied with Ampliphone Vector monitors in both the upright and the cockpit. I have also learned that it is these which are considered the weak point in the cabs in regards to breakdowns. Hence, alot of operators chose to replace the Ampliphone monitors with WG 6100 variants instead for reliability.

Now it would appear that the Ampliphone monitor is much more desirable than the WG simply because the Ampliphone gives much smoother vector lines, is that right?

My question is, why would operators replace the Ampliphone's with WG's instead of simply repairing them? Were they really THAT unreliable? If that is the case, why would most collectors (of whom most are non-tech) want an Ampliphone instead of a WG?

To confuse even more, I have read that the Ampliphone deflection is easier to repair than the WG??

Lastly, compared to Asteroids, there appears to be very little Repair logs or even threads on repairs to Star Wars PCBs. Why is this? Are the Star Wars PCB sets much more reliable than Asteroids or do the same rules apply when it comes to failures and repairs?

Thanks
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
This is a long story. Someone like P-man will probably froth at the mouth at this so expect a long response sooner or later.

1. The Amplfiones had notoriously unreliable High Voltage Transformers (there's a mythical story about water in the factory etc blah blah)

2. There was no replacement HVT - so you just got another sh*t one.

3. The deflection board is awesome, but went through a few revisions, with some modifications/revisions sent out in paper form after the last rev board was made.

4. All in all, the Amplifone monitors started failing, and operators just stuck their known 'more' reliable WG6100's in

The Amplifone is superior in nearly all regards to the WG6100. In having a med res tube and also a faster slew rate (faster vectors, support for more rigorous vector games (Major Havoc/Quantum)

A replacement HVT is out now. in the late 80's this was the Pentran. They got bought out by Wintron. Then Cinelabs made one.

So to summarise, a rebuilt Amplifone HV and deflection board with new HVT and all the recommended modifications/updates totally blows a WG6100 away.

Therefore it is more desirable as it is a)original and b)just better.

I put the reliability of a rebuilt Amplifone above a rebuilt WG6100.

Oliver
 

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR
The flyback in the original Amplifone HT boards had a tendency to break* (google dead red amplifone) so the monitors were pulled out after dying and replaced with WGs which were lying around. I believe Atari came out with a replacement part at some point but I guess Ops weren't too bothered about doing the extra work to restore the original monitors as the games were still taking cash.

It's been ages since I played SW with a WG in it so I can't recall what it was like, but I have an Amp 25" in my cockpit and it's freaking awesome! It's a higher resolution than a WG and also has a faster response time, plus it's the monitor the game was designed for.

I'm definitely not put off, in fact I was waiting for one with the original 25", by having an Amp in my SWC as there is a new Cinelabs flyback (http://www.cinelabs.com/amp/ I bought some off ebay for about £20 a pop the other week - see link in ebay section) which doesn't ignite like the original so it's possible to make the boards much more reliable now.

Having had an explanation of a WG deflection setup versus the Amp deflection from P-Man yesterday I think I'd prefer fixing an Amp deflection board purely because they're a self contained unit and are much easier to stop from overheating - just install a fan and don't worry about vector wiggle either.

I think the reason there are less SW repair logs is because it's a bitch of a board - a three layer stack with a rigid backplane so I don't expect it to be much fun when it comes to working on it and I probably wouldn't have the energy left after fixing it to write it up :) But if you look in the right places you'll find plenty of info on SW boards (vectorlist archives are probably a good place to start).

I do have an untested SW boardset which I want to test before it's warm enough to start playing on the cab again so there'll be a test log minimum on here at some point. Hopefully not a repair log as the set was sold as "last tested working before 12m storage"
smiley2.gif
.

But the picture on the Amp is just gorgeous
smiley27.gif


t

ps I believe there is also an issue with pincushion correction when the monitor is swapped. It's some combination of one part doing pincushion correction either on the PCB or the deflection so when you swap in a WG you either don't have pincushion correction, or you have too much. I can't remember the details but I'm pretty sure Oll, Dan or P-man will be able to expand on this or point out it's a different vector setup that was affected.

* Depending on which source you believe the problem with the original flybacks was caused by poor humidity control in the factory, through to some visiting Atari exec insisting on smoking inside which caused sprinklers to set off. Jed Margolin has an interesting write-up on his website - I think he went with the smoking/sprinklers tale.
 

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR

Equites

Chief Sheesher®
vacBacker
Feedback
35 (100%)
Credits
3,329CR
Thanks guys

That answers all my questions, it's a shame really, I guess most of the Amp monitors simply got skipped. I take it that there is no new equivalent CRT replacement tube available either?

Alpha1 said:
The Amplifone is superior in nearly all regards to the WG6100. In having a med res tube and also a faster slew rate (faster vectors, support for more rigorous vector games (Major Havoc/Quantum)

Never knew these came with an Amp too, I assumed it was only Star Wars.

trmatthe said:
But if you're after a SW, try for the cockpit as it's so much more enjoyable to play, jammed in your TIE fighter and go for an Amplifone setup. Play the game as it was intended to be played :)

Yes I would love a cockpit, although even an upright will do but MUST have an Amp in there as you say.

The last cockpit with an Amp that I know of that was sold was by Ol to a chap in North Wales who never got it running because he have noooo tech sense at all. A shame, he did beg me to come and have a look at it for him but I'm not familiar with these beasts.
Equites2011-02-24 16:55:39
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
I gave my last tube to Rav in December for his Major Havoc.

I have none left.

Don't be put off buying a MINT Starwars upright with a WG6100 versus a shagged one with an Amplifone.

I got a minty minty Starwars upright with a WG6100, and simply got a completely rebuilt Amplifone off Darin Jacobs (PhoenixArcade) a few years back to put in it. It's pin for pin compatible so just plug and play.

Some SW cockpits run WG6100s, finding a 25" Amplifone is WAY WAY harder. I have had to buy entire Starwars cockpits just to get a 25" tube to put in another....

I disagree with Tim - I think the upright is just as cool looking as the sitdown - and I actually find it easier to play for extended periods on.
 

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR
The guy at RAM Controls is supposedly remaking Amp 25" equivalents. He's posted on his site about receiving a satisfactory prototype and going ahead with a production run but as you may be aware there are people who aren't happy with his delivery schedule and allegedly rumours that all isn't what it seems.

I just want to make it clear I have no idea what's true and what isn't, but it may be that there will be a source of repro tubes. I mailed him about these in the past but didn't receive a reply unfortunately. He's listing them at $325 incl yoke and I'd buy one in an instant :)

I remember the guy who bought a SWC and then seemed intent on totally shagging it - have you contacted him about taking it off his hands?
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
Forgot to add,

Even though I prefer the upright for extended play, the cockpit is still uber cool. I lub them both
smiley27.gif
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
trmatthe said:
The guy at RAM Controls is supposedly remaking Amp 25" equivalents. He's posted on his site about receiving a satisfactory prototype and going ahead with a production run but as you may be aware there are people who aren't happy with his delivery schedule and allegedly rumours that all isn't what it seems.

I just want to make it clear I have no idea what's true and what isn't, but it may be that there will be a source of repro tubes. I mailed him about these in the past but didn't receive a reply unfortunately. He's listing them at $325 incl yoke and I'd buy one in an instant :)

I remember the guy who bought a SWC and then seemed intent on totally shagging it - have you contacted him about taking it off his hands?

Avoid RAM at all costs - I have been on the recieving end of this c**t, he's a complete con artist.

This thread stands at about $60,000 USD owed at the moment:

http://forums.arcade-museum.com/showthread.php?t=162144

3 people are out $3000USD and 1 for $5000USD. Check where he tries to be someone else to get the Amplifone NOS CRTs shipped elsewhere and the blatant lies on product that simply doesn't exist.

Alpha12011-02-24 17:11:56
 

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR
Alpha1 said:
I disagree with Tim - I think the upright is just as cool looking as the sitdown - and I actually find it easier to play for extended periods on.

It is pretty uncomfortable to play in for extended periods, but I'm so crap I don't normally have that problem. I can get out and stretch my legs in between games, so I'm probably only sitting for for about 3-5 mins max
smiley36.gif
.

I think the UR has a very striking look and it's certainly a very nice looking cab but for me nothing beats a nice condition SWC. Part is from the cockpit being one of the only games I remember playing when I was younger and the other aspect is that you're squidged in there in the dark with a massive screen in front of you and sound booming from all around. Awesome, especially with an SW/ESB multigame!
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
trmatthe said:
Alpha1 said:
I disagree with Tim - I think the upright is just as cool looking as the sitdown - and I actually find it easier to play for extended periods on.

It is pretty uncomfortable to play in for extended periods, but I'm so crap I don't normally have that problem. I can get out and stretch my legs in between games, so I'm probably only sitting for for about 3-5 mins max
smiley36.gif
.

I think the UR has a very striking look and it's certainly a very nice looking cab but for me nothing beats a nice condition SWC. Part is from the cockpit being one of the only games I remember playing when I was younger and the other aspect is that you're squidged in there in the dark with a massive screen in front of you and sound booming from all around. Awesome, especially with an SW/ESB multigame!

Best game I ever had I had Mark (leopardcats) round I played for about 20 minutes scoring 3.8 million. He was impressed!

I have both anyhow so I don't have to worry which one is best
smiley30.gif


Alpha12011-02-24 17:16:38
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
Equites said:
Thanks guys

That answers all my questions, it's a shame really, I guess most of the Amp monitors simply got skipped. I take it that there is no new equivalent CRT replacement tube available either?

Alpha1 said:
The Amplifone is superior in nearly all regards to the WG6100. In having a med res tube and also a faster slew rate (faster vectors, support for more rigorous vector games (Major Havoc/Quantum)

Never knew these came with an Amp too, I assumed it was only Star Wars.

trmatthe said:
But if you're after a SW, try for the cockpit as it's so much more enjoyable to play, jammed in your TIE fighter and go for an Amplifone setup. Play the game as it was intended to be played :)

Yes I would love a cockpit, although even an upright will do but MUST have an Amp in there as you say.

The last cockpit with an Amp that I know of that was sold was by Ol to a chap in North Wales who never got it running because he have noooo tech sense at all. A shame, he did beg me to come and have a look at it for him but I'm not familiar with these beasts.

That was a lovely LOVELY Starwars cockpit - only a few knocks on one side, easily fixed up. It had a 25" Amplifone. The pix are here: http://www.arcadeoll.com/pics/SWC/ please someone save it - I even considered trying to buy it back as I was worried what will happen to it.

Alpha12011-02-24 17:17:36
 

Equites

Chief Sheesher®
vacBacker
Feedback
35 (100%)
Credits
3,329CR
trmatthe said:
I remember the guy who bought a SWC and then seemed intent on totally shagging it - have you contacted him about taking it off his hands?

Yes, I did try and contact him but he has dissapeared since Xmas, no sign of him so I do not know what has happended. I would love to take it off him but this guy always wants a premium for the stuff he has for sale but expects to buy stuff at rock bottom. He would often PM me with offers for stuff I had for sale at half the asking price. I would pay the going rate for one though no problem.

Alpha1 said:
Avoid RAM at all costs - I have been on the recieving end of this c**t, he's a complete con artist.

I wish I had known before, now I know what happened to the $400 I had sent RAM for NOS IC's. I guess I will never see that money again or the IC's for that matter.
Equites2011-02-24 17:19:58
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
Equites said:
I wish I had known before, now I know what happened to the $400 I had sent RAM for NOS IC's. I guess I will never see that money again or the IC's for that matter.

Add yourself to that thread. They are using it to start legal proceedings I think. He f**ked me over on IC's about 4 years ago, I got him on the phone and had to threaten to fly over there before I got my money back. The sad thing was it never came back from his Paypal account, so someone else re-imbursed me and it does bother me that maybe they then got scammed.
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
Equites said:
Yes, I did try and contact him but he has dissapeared since Xmas, no sign of him so I do not know what has happended. I would love to take it off him but this guy always wants a premium for the stuff he has for sale but expects to buy stuff at rock bottom. He would often PM me with offers for stuff I had for sale at half the asking price. I would pay the going rate for one though no problem.

I have his mobile number I think still - i'll try and find it. He got it off me for £1500 (but when I later counted the cash there was only £1400!!!)
 

Equites

Chief Sheesher®
vacBacker
Feedback
35 (100%)
Credits
3,329CR
Alpha1 said:
I have his mobile number I think still - i'll try and find it. He got it off me for £1500 (but when I later counted the cash there was only £1400!!!)

Cheeky bugger, you are like me, I never count cash either. People NEVER make mistakes with cash.
 

trm

Who loves you, and who do you love?
Feedback
2 (100%)
Credits
2,877CR
I didn't want to say too much about RAM as I couldn't provide any links to backup what I was saying but the links from Oll above speak for themselves. It's a real shame as I've got a yoke rebuild kit which is excellent.
 

Alpha1

Do the Shake and 'VAC
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
95 (99%)
Credits
5,653CR
trmatthe said:
I didn't want to say too much about RAM as I couldn't provide any links to backup what I was saying but the links from Oll above speak for themselves. It's a real shame as I've got a yoke rebuild kit which is excellent.

If you have an hour or so - go through the entire thread - it's shocking.
 
Top