Desoldering (Again!)

dj_yt

Active member
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
787CR
Hello,

A while ago I was doing some board repairs, and a bunch of you gave me some feedback on improving my desoldering techniques. They helped at the time.

However, I want to make desoldering easier still. Right now I'm working on Sega multi-layer PCBs with enormous ground planes. These are difficult to desolder from. I was chatting to Mark from Retroclinic and he mentioned he had to pretty much use an iron at 450c for 10-20 seconds to loosen a pin.

In my case, I struggle further. Sometimes it takes about 20 mins to loosen a ground pin (re-solder/suck solder/try again). This clearly is ridiculous and not a practical use of time - plus I worry that I'll damage a board by spending so long messing about with a single pin. I need a faster way of working on these boards and would welcome advice. I'm pretty sure it's not my technique, but actually my tools as I can easily desolder from simpler PCBs and pins that don't carry ground or power even on a multi-layer board.

Right now my setup is basic:

60W Soldering Iron:

http://www.maplin.co.uk/p/60w-mains-lcd-solder-station-a55kj

Actually a nice iron for basic tasks in my opinion. Would more wattage help or a better quality brand?

Duratool Desoldering Station

Should I just bite the bullet and upgrade to a Hakko? I've been tempted, but I need to be sure this will really make a difference before spending £250.

I've also tried good quality braid, the application of flux, a decent hand pump etc. The thickness of the board and the number of layers just mean it's difficult to fully clear the hole.

Thanks!
 

Ace`

PlanB contributor #1
Feedback
40 (100%)
Credits
4,038CR
Depending how much you're going to use it I'd say a Hakko is well worth the money and far better than any of the knock offs or any of the cheaper ones. I'd go for a station rather than one of those all in one guns like the 808 personally. If you want to save money (the new station is about £550) look out for a second hand model and dancap.co.uk should have all the parts to refurb it if it's not too old.
 

Monstermug

Active member
Feedback
23 (100%)
Credits
1,807CR
Have you tried this? I still prefer to use this over my Metcal. I used it to suck up a spider that I found crawling under a 74LS191 the other day
smiley36.gif


20170221_175931.jpg
 
G

Guests

Guest
I'm not the biggest expert at soldering ever but I'm pretty sure a 60 watt iron is way too hot for PCB work.

I have a Maplins temperature controlled iron and it has never let me down, done well over 120 SEGA Game Gear recaps and loads of other stuff.

http://www.maplin.co.uk/p/maplin-50w-mains-solder-station-n78ar

I've purchased many irons including the much loved Antex offerings but honestly, this is the best i've owned overall.

rotunda2017-03-30 00:56:04
 

joe34

Active member
Credits
448CR
Monstermug said:
Have you tried this?

hey MM, i like the look of that so just nabbed one off ebay
smiley1.gif


how often do you find you have to change the silicone nozzle? i have 4 vectrex's (3 not working) where i want to socket all of the chips so i figure that's gonna be hundreds of solder joints to get through
 

dj_yt

Active member
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
787CR
I've got that exact solder sucker you mention monstermug.

The problem here is that on a 4 layer PCB with massive ground plane, you simply can't get enough heat through the PCB to make effective use of it.

Snipping the component and removing the leg by attacking the board from both sides is a solution to this, but it's a pain and time consuming. I want to be able to cleanly remove components without the faff!

I'm pretty sure a weaker wattage soldering iron would make the problem worse. I'm guessing a Game Gear PCB is much thinner than a 4 layer Afterburner PCB. (even a system16 PCB presents few problems in comparison)

Note that removing new solder isnt a problem, it's the factory installed components that are a bitch!

dj_yt2017-03-30 08:21:12
 

Hurray Banana

Moderator
Staff member
vacBacker
Feedback
8 (100%)
Credits
2,756CR
Monstermug said:
Have you tried this? I still prefer to use this over my Metcal. I used it to suck up a spider that I found crawling under a 74LS191 the other day
smiley36.gif


20170221_175931.jpg

This is a great sucker.

Also try adding fresh solder before desoldering
 

dj_yt

Active member
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
787CR
I'm using fresh solder. Just doesn't clear all the way through the hole consistently for ground and power. Like I mentioned, I think it's a heat dissipation problem rather than suction.
 

Ronnie Dent

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
15 (100%)
Credits
1,206CR
Have heard of people adding heat from the parts side with iron them sucking from the solder side? I would find that awkward unless you have a rig to prop the board upright!
 

vib_ribbon

Active member
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
488CR
Ronnie Dent said:
Have heard of people adding heat from the parts side with iron them sucking from the solder side? I would find that awkward unless you have a rig to prop the board upright!

I know the OP's pain, i think i made a thread just like this when i first started out.

I do exactly this. I have a table clamp that has rubber jaw covers. i would clamp the pcb so both solder & component sides are vertical. I then heat the leg on the component side with my soldering iron and suck with my desoldering iron on the solder side of the pcb.

What I also find useful is to use the smallest hole nozzle possible on the desoldering iron, so the amount of suction pressure is the highest possible. I also dab some flux on the leg before I start.

Good luck.
 

Monstermug

Active member
Feedback
23 (100%)
Credits
1,807CR
joe34 said:
Monstermug said:
Have you tried this?

hey MM, i like the look of that so just nabbed one off ebay
smiley1.gif


how often do you find you have to change the silicone nozzle? i have 4 vectrex's (3 not working) where i want to socket all of the chips so i figure that's gonna be hundreds of solder joints to get through

On average about 1000 pins. I find the silicon nozzle wears off because I have to dig out the solder with a tweezer and that sometimes rip the silicon rather than through normal use. I found a trick where if you lubricate the nozzle with high temp grease, the solder just falls right out.

Regarding the OP's, have you tried solder wick on the parts side to remove the solder and then suck up the rest on the solder side? A combination of this and heating the ground plain for 10-15 seconds before sucking it up. That works for me on big ground plains. If not then heating from the component side usually does the trick but on big boards or boards that are multiple layers is a pain. Last resort would be to cut the pins but that's always a messy job which I avoid at all cost.
 

dj_yt

Active member
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
787CR
Monstermug said:
Regarding the OP's, have you tried solder wick on the parts side to remove the solder and then suck up the rest on the solder side? A combination of this and heating the ground plain for 10-15 seconds before sucking it up. That works for me on big ground plains. If not then heating from the component side usually does the trick but on big boards or boards that are multiple layers is a pain. Last resort would be to cut the pins but that's always a messy job which I avoid at all cost.

Yes. That's another technique I've used that works a little better.

My main desire/dream is to be able to desolder from one side only, so that I don't have to completely snip components. Maybe I'm expecting too much.

I've just picked up the older Hakko 808 cheaply on eBay, that appears in decent condition. Good timing. I'll give that a spin and report back.
 

jonhughes

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
52 (100%)
Credits
1,156CR
Right now my setup is basic:

60W Soldering Iron:

http://www.maplin.co.uk/p/60w-mains-lcd-solder-station-a55kj

Actually a nice iron for basic tasks in my opinion. Would more wattage help or a better quality brand?

This is the soldering iron I use. I couldn't say if you would get better results from a more expensive iron. What I have found is more what preparation and consumables you use for the de-soldering process. I removed one of those time keeper RAMs from a System 573 not long ago using this iron (see fix logs) - but it required a fair amount of prep to the solder eyes and then there's the patience and technique (which is hard to put across in words to be frank).

http://www.ukvac.com/forum/konami-system-573_topic356769.html

A solder sucker is fairly useless on one of these multi-layer PCBs (for me) but they are without doubt the best thing to use on early PCBs - I can change a standard socket in minutes.

I use this and it is awesome on the right kind of PCB:

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/like/191879816040?chn=ps&adgroupid=40176066202&rlsatarget=pla-279594463825&abcId=923916&adtype=pla&merchantid=109775182&poi=&googleloc=9045255&device=c&campaignid=738210941&crdt=0

jonhughes2017-03-30 12:12:58
 

Kaizen088

User
Credits
130CR
I agree with the previous comments in regard to heating from one side and use the solder sucker from the other side.
My soldering/desoldering was terrible until I bought a Weller Temperature Controlled Soldering Iron.



When faced with having to resocket 24 RAMs on a Defender board you have to do it right.





I get by with just a solder sucker but from experience I've found the following important to do a good job.

I clean all traces of previous flux from the area I'm working on.

A clean soldering iron tip is a must.

I use a clear liquid flux that comes in a bottle like nail polish.

When removing a chip intact, I apply the flux then tin the legs with fresh solder before trying to clear the hole.

If the pin is slightly touching the through hole you can pull it away while the area is still hot if you're quick enough, otherwise push it a little with the soldering iron but I prefer not to do that.

I have two different solder suckers, one is large and plastic and has a softer action to it.

The other is smaller and has an aluminium body (next to soldering iron in the first pic)and a much sharper spring action with a finer tip .

I've found if I don't clear the hole after two goes I switch to the other which usually does the trick.

If I feel the PCB is getting too hot I'll leave it and come back again later, better than cooking the board and lifting tracks.

When doing the ground planes I try to suck up as much solder from the area surrounding the hole before heating from the opposite side and using the solder sucker on the plane side.

I manage to balance the PCB on the solder sucker the heat from the opposite side, fortunately I don't have to do this too often.

I manage to get by but there's always a better way but I don't intend on buying a desoldering station when a solder sucker will do the job for most 80's PCBs

Kaizen0882017-03-30 13:32:53
 

dj_yt

Active member
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
787CR
jonhughes said:
This is the soldering iron I use. I couldn't say if you would get better results from a more expensive iron. What I have found is more what preparation and consumables you use for the de-soldering process. I removed one of those time keeper RAMs from a System 573 not long ago using this iron (see fix logs) - but it required a fair amount of prep to the solder eyes and then there's the patience and technique (which is hard to put across in words to be frank).

Yes, I'd previously read your fix log. It was very interesting - mostly because you run into some of the same issues that I have! It's also good, as you have experience of how much tougher the multi layer boards can be. Unfortunately much of the online advice assumes you're working with a simpler PCB, and let's face it there's a world of difference between a late 80s AfterBurner board and an Asteroids in terms of how they are constructed :)

I'll experiment with some of the ideas that have been suggested with regard to using flux on the legs and other preparation techniques to make the process run smoother.
 

jonhughes

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
52 (100%)
Credits
1,156CR
Heating the PCB from one side and using the solder sucker on the other side would be very tricky, I would imagine. I have something like this contraption:

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Duratool-D03170-Pcb-Holder-/132005288283

but I hardly ever use it and never thought about using it for working on both sides of the PCB at the same time. If solder won't remove from the eye I normally drill it out. Takes about half a minute to a minute. I find this far less riskier than ploughing heat into the PCB. I feel you could never see what you are doing well enough not to cause any damage on the iron heating side if you were working on both sides of board.

I guess it's a case of what works best.

P.S. those old midway PCBs are an absolute pleasure to work on compared to a multi-layer PCB.

jonhughes2017-03-30 14:54:57
 

ColinD

Active member
Feedback
6 (86%)
Credits
1,367CR
Get a hot air station for about £80 , and give the board area a nice gentle heat up. Also leave the hot air on while de-soldeing the pins. This stops the ground / power planes sucking as much heat away from the desoldering tool as they are hot already. Don't get the pcb 'TOO hot' though !!
 

dj_yt

Active member
Feedback
3 (100%)
Credits
787CR
Just to close this one off, I bought a cheap second hand Hakko 808 off eBay, and fitted it with some new parts from dancap.

Managed to easily remove a bunch of components tonight cleanly, without resorting to snipping legs, pre-heating or heating the board from both sides.

This thing is a beast compared with the tools I was using before. I suspect it's overkill for simple work, but for this PCB it works wonders.
 
Top