Linear or Switch Mode PSU?

badgerme

Active member
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
49CR
Ok so I bought a BAS Jamma cab about a month back and I've replaced all of the harness as it was missing solder points for buttons 4, 5 and 6 and it was badly soldered and hacked a bit.

The Hantarex US 250 power supply was outputting 4.75 on the 5v, -3.3 on the -5 rail and about 10.5 on the 12 volt rail (under load), so I thought best change the PSU (even though it boots games and runs fine)

I've put in a brand new MWP-606 from ArcadeWorldUK and the voltages are now spot on, however having spoking with my Dad (who was a television engineer for 30 years), hes told me that the original power supply (if repaired and recapped) is less likely to kill my PCB if parts of it fail as if parts of it fail, as voltages will just go down. A switch mode powersupply (if parts fail) would give a high voltage output which will most likely kill the PCB.

So I'm stuck in a dilemma. Do I repair the original Hantarex US 250 PSU by recapping and use that (still with mostly 30 year old components) or do I continue to use the new MWP-606 switch mode power supply that's brand new? At the end of the day, I want to try and protect me valuable, irreplaceable PCBs!

What do you guys generally do? Recap the original PSU or change to a new switch mode PSU?

Thanks in advance!
 

karlcdoe

Active member
vacBacker
Feedback
8 (100%)
Credits
887CR
Ignoring specific models with bad fail rates I thought the opposite was true?

Unless there is some additional inbuilt protection on the circuit most of the linears I have worked on basically step down mains voltage, rectify it to some low DC value and then a large bottle cap transistor is basically all that stands between the pcb and the voltage coming out if the transformer.

I don't think I've ever had a switch mode fail in such a manner that it puts out too high a voltage apart from a bad adjustment pot.

I have had linears fail in such a manner that they are putting 7-9 volts out on the 5volt line.

Having said that I find linears easier to fix.

Maybe I'm just a luck SoB but be interested in others comments.
 

RSwanson

User
Feedback
1 (100%)
Credits
205CR
"Linear or Switch Mode PSU?"[/b]

They're both switch mode psu's. The US 250 is an early version of an SMPS. It's really awful. It can fail in a way that sends overvoltage to both the game PCB and monitor. I had a monitor catch fire when this happened.

We could argue all day over which is best, Linear or SMPS, it depends on a number of factors. I personally believe that SMPS should only be used when a manufacturer produced a notoriously bad Linear PSU, otherwise, the Linear PSU will easily out live a SMPS (with the odd basic repair every 5-10years, and generally have much lower ripple and noise.

My Atari AR3 produces just 15mV ripple, whilst a new SMPS I recently bought (that measured 5.1v with the multimeter) was showing a ripple current of 300mV, and the -5v can be all over the place, which is not good for older boards when it's powering CPUs/RAM.
 

badgerme

Active member
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
49CR
So swapping out my Hantarex US 250 to power the game pcb board for a brand new MWP-606 is a good move in protecting my precious valuable PCB's?
badgerme2018-01-25 14:10:23
 

obcd

Active member
Credits
3,830CR
Well, as they are both switchers. The Hantarex had it's years of use. The new switcher is...new.

I assume you won't run your arcade 12 hours a day 7 days a week. This might have happened to that US250 for several years. So, basically, I would vote for the new supply.

Dad's aren't always right.
obcd2018-01-25 22:55:20
 

IanH

User
Credits
277CR
I've only ever seen a smpsu take a game board out once in 25 odd years ( god has it been that long), and that was a ridge racer with a standard smpsu. Keep using your new one.
Cheers
Ian
 

badgerme

Active member
Feedback
5 (100%)
Credits
49CR
Thanks Ian! I’ve never been so paranoid about power supplies since I’ve started to collect my rare favourite old games! Makes me not want to pay them for fear of the power supply killing them! Silly I know!
 
Top