I still don't get it. The purpose of VAT is to provide revenue income from the sale of luxury goods. These are often resold items which would have been subject to VAT at the time of
first purchase, not if sold again by a private seller.
The rules within the UK are clear and I believe are as follows:
1. If the sellers gross earnings from the sale of goods (their business) are above £85000 then they must keep accounts, register and pay VAT on VAT payable goods.
2. If goods are at the reduced rate or tax exempt (e.g. Children's Clothes, Books etc.) then the correct rate of tax must be applied.
A blanket 20% tax is wrong. It is actually illegal to mislabel things that are VAT exempt. Ebay is simply a selling platform, not a means of collecting tax.
Edit:
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/rates-of-vat-on-different-goods-and-services
You'd need to ask a tax expert but at a push you could say that arcade machine parts come under "Betting and gaming – including pool betting and games of chance" and are tax exempt whereas an inflatable model of Ursula von der Leyen (fnarr, fnarr) is +20%
mlynn2021-01-06 00:52:36